Part 1: Accountability, PR middle name?
- In the first part of my write up, I wrote on the Accountability which is the second component of PR motto. Today I will address the issue of competency which is the first of the three motto of PR. A competent government is a government that is able to run things efficiently and the effect can be felt when ordinary people is dealing with the various state government agencies. Both the Penang and Selangor government claims that they are competent. Maybe both governments should commission an independent audit to look into this matter and present it the stakeholder i.e. the rakyat on the differences in competency before and after 2008. At the same time we must take note that the AG has given very good rating to both the government.
- Before anyone accuses me of being UMNO lap dog for attacking PR, please take note that my opinion has always been that people interest should be the centre stage of any political battle. I speak my mind out of love of the people and not about hatred against any PR representatives. It is an open secret that I don’t think very highly of Azmin Ali as an ADUN or MP based on my assessment where service to the people is concern. The way I see it, he is NATO i.e. No action, talk only which is no different than those loud peddlers in the night market. When people in dire straits need help, they don’t want to hear empty promises. They don’t like to hear; “saya akan arahkan MPAJ”, when clearly when the ADUN has no authority to “arah” or “saya akan pastikan” when the ADUN don’t explain on how he plans to “pastikan (ensure)”. The other thing that pissed me off when ADUN would say “saya akan desak..”. Desak? For god sake, when the ADUN is part of the government of the day and we don’t expect you to ‘desak”. The people are “terdesak” and they have been “mendesak”. We expect the ADUN to do something that is objective and clear. We live in the 21st century and the people no longer have appetite for such vague responses. They had enough of such responses before 308 and would expect a change after 308. Unfortunately this did not happen.
- Let us look at SSG. Since 308, the local council member has been elected from their political nominees. For the record they did not fulfilled their promises on local government election (which I accept their reasons for it but cannot accept their lack of creativity in handling the matter.) How many of us know that in several local council in Selangor, the state has failed to nominate people before the end of the term. In fact the current council member’s term has been extended. For 3 years in a row they have not been nominating council members on time. Is this a hallmark of a competent government? We all know that council members suppose to serve for a period of 12 months and subject to re-nomination. Why such a simple thing cannot be done? Already election cannot be done and simple thing like planning and coordination also cannot be done efficiently. Isn’t it embarrassing to acclaimed that one is competent when in actual fact it is not?
Comments Policy: All rights reserved.
The writing in this post represents the views of R2W. However the comments do not represent the views of the author but represent the view of the commentator. R2W welcome all constructive comments and reserved the rights to delete or edit any comments that are deem as vulgar, abusive, racist, sexist or seditious in nature. R2W is not able to moderate all comments. Commentators are requested to be professional in expressing their views and be fully responsible for the comments made.
Advertisement
I read the news of ukay bistari on today oriental daily, rafick name was there, did a fantastic job and my salute. Nor Omar mentioned that by coincidence, rakick seek his help. Just curious, what is by coincidence? You two meet up during a teh tarik session?
see the video where not explains that we hijacked Noh Omar from an official event in melawati
Rhan, You promise me to give Rafick a whacking if he misbehaves, didn’t you? Just curious whether you already did? Please mind your spelling Rhan.. it is Rafick not RaKick ya. But don’t bother it does sound similar.
Rhan, can you please tell him once and for all to decide which side of the fence he want to sit and stop being the little boy water carrier! Or does he still wants to be the Head Cowboy of NFC? Then we can understand why he has to scratch Noh’s back!
dont know how to respond to people like you! sorry
Hi Sally, and to rafick sorry for the wrong name bec my maxis broadband keep dropping so I have to type fast and dun bother to check, thinking of getting a celcom (no promotion yet) or unifi later on bec maxis cs tell me they cant do much beside asking me to log in / out and change some setting, I am now more knowledgeable than the cs, in fact they successfully transforming me into believing that this is the service I deserve. So either change the service provider (make no diff anyway) or change the government (this might help more, never try never know). Back to your question, my personal view is that we shd detach the role of blogger that commenting on national issue and ngo role that try to assist the sufferers, priority is different and one is accountable for being the post he is holding, but I agree some of his comment sound bitter toward AA and SSG, pretty amusing, have an axe to grind
Btw, will more victims help to pressurize the government to work harder and make them look like one that care? So the first step must increase the number of victim. Rhan
PR SSG may not be perfect…
Abdul Ibrahim,
This is the first time I heard Faekah Husin speaking. Crystal clear. Thanks.
p/s Ellese said “personal interest (PKR}”… my mind wonders..
This is also the first time I heard Faekah speaking and yesterday I heard Noh Omar spoke at the handing over of keys to part of the UkayBistari project. Both political speaches I take with a pinch of salt and analyse the content and intent (yang tersurat dan tersirat) and not get overly excited.
The checks-and-balances are what we need in this country and if and when both the ruling party and a strong opposition party are able to work positively instead of garbage politics, this will augur well for the rakyat.
Bro…
Faekah’s speech cannot be heard over TV3 etc etc… she does not have the freedom of expression, so to speak. News like this from Abdul Ibrahim are parodied, not represented by the media. I am sorry I disagree with you a bit… because some speeches do not deserve the ear of sensible, rational individuals, even if they could be heard above the shattering clamour of thunderous claps.
Zul,
Yes , some speeches are not worth listening but you will know only after listening, no ! I listen to both sides with a lot of salt and I make my own conclusion avoiding being too judemental on others. Hati mesti selalu baik, bro !
Bro…
In my twilight years if I Allah can accept what I am doing now… it is enough for me. Soal hati is for Allah to judge… not you, not me! Who are we to judge what is inside people’s heart! Only God could see what is inside my heart.! I have listen enough to both sides BN & PR and I’ve made own conclusion for PRU13 long time ago… you can ask Doc.. Am I being too judgmental? Or are insinuating my hati tak selalu baik?
Bro,
No, do not get me wrong. The others include you as I am critical of my own self rather on others.
Bro..
Sometimes it is not possible to see the other side’s objectivity with any objectivity, let alone comprehend its arguments, when one’s own value, is seen as the fundamental value to which all other values must defer.
Therefore, I am mutually aligned with your statement.. “The checks-and-balances are what we need in this country and if and when both the ruling party and a strong opposition party are able to work positively instead of garbage politics, this will augur well for the rakyat.”
True… the winner will be the rakyat, e.g. the UK Bistari case.
Abdul Ibrahim,
I look at VICTIMS’ UKB case as a social and political necessity within and between the rakyat and the state. Unfortunately, AA and SSG do not see it that way. The way forward is to bring social responsibility into the equation and recognize that a man is as great as the responsibility he/she shows to the rakyat.
Zul
I agree. There is a need to reduce the gap between state and the people.
Instead of helping AA even when a step further and insulted me several days ago on twitter where he says he does not want to meet rich people like me who do things for self interest. He says he will help others. To be a member of victims one must have personal interest i.e. must have abandon project. Firstly, I am not rich. I live in a terrace house. I own 3 cars but all them is valued at RM30K each as we bought them second hand. Reality is he lives in a mansion at Taman TAR with expensive cars. That to me is an insult as well as a smart way of avoiding responsibility.
I offered him on twitter to meet all the purchasers where I will organize the event ask him to explain to the buyers what he has done. He refuses and replied by saying ” Saudara boleh teruskan cerca dan propaganda bersama Noh Omar” I have kept the trail of all the tweets. I will produce it on my blog when the time is right. For your record, Not once I had insulted him but as usual he negates responsibility by sidetracking the matter.Is this a mark of a good leader. He even blocked me on twitter subsequently. There are thousands of people who cursed Najib on twitter and FB. He did not block any of the posting and followers
Fact remains everyone can appreciate from my writings from 2007 on my political stand. I have a lot of sympathy for PR. I defended him on allegation by FMT to smear his name about PJ Sentral Development (google Azmin and Puncak Wangi). I had given him a lot of chance and handicapped. I had given him ample opportunity to come forward and act. He sits on PKNS board, surely he has the access on how to get things done. I have realized that this is not the guy that will dirty his hands for others. Several resident association heads in BA also tells me the same. This guy has no time for his constituency. He has a bigger agenda for himself.
During the event in front of BN leaders, I openly praised YB Saari Sungib from PAS and did mentioned some kind words about YB Zuraida. I said nothing about Azmin because he does not deserve it. I felt like saying AA did nothing but I chose not to do so after listening to my friend who is my association deputy. I suppose by not mentioning AA name yesterday says it loud enough!. I don’t see BN leaders being offended when I mentioned Saari Sungib name because they all know SS did something before they came in for the low cost unit 146 in 2009.Noh Omar only came in much later.
After I mentioned what Noh Omar did, the crowd gave him a standing ovation. He deserves it. Dato Noh in his speech said that “Dr Rafick ni keras orangnya.. Dato Chor menteri perumahan complain dan berdasarkan pengalaman beliau berurusan dengan saya semasa crisis PIBG di sekolah anak dia tapi but he also said ” Dia keras bukan untuk diri sendiri tapi untuk sekolah dan isu setempat seperti UKB”
Many people don’t know what happen at KPKT in the early days. We started with diplomacy but when diplomacy failed We shouted and bang table because there KPKT officers wants to be neutral and do not want to be on our sides” I don’t give face to any officers who does not do their part for us.
Bro. Why mention my name?:-) i can’t see an ideological underpinning behind pkr save for self and power bro. What to do? For politicians you must always see the action and not merely the words as talk and promises are cheap for them. None knows what is right or wrong. I already alluded before Faekah has this mindset of banning ibrahim Ali from selangor as she is upset with IA’s claim. That itself shows her character.
My apology bro for mentioning your name.
PKR has UMNO dna…the very bedrock of its identity is thus constantly open to question, abuse and ridicule. And I thought Faekah speaks with self-righteous certainty in the correctness of her views.
Another one…
Based on what I know
(1) Talam paid cash RM50 mill
(2) Land was put as collateral and will be forfeited if not paid. The forfeit process is on going and is being challenged by Talam
(3) On one parcel of land, the MB announced that they have taken back but not clear where is the land.
(4) Faeqah mentioned that a big parcel of land of about 1000 acres-which has been redesigned and the GDV now is 1.2 bill. Please understand that it is a conceptual approach. Until the development materialized and property sold there is no !.2bill
In Ukay Bistari and other Talam related projects, I have written so many times to MB to request to meet and had also proposed that he uses the same approach with solving abandon houses- He had refuses to acknowledge. He has cloud over Talam and should be able to leverage and get agencies like PKNS to complete the houses. He did not do it and did not even grant us a meeting to even consider our idea or explain to us why it cannot be done in such a manner.He could do the same debt restructure and take over abandon project easily and in exchange take over some Talam land bank.
Macam koridor-koridor Pak Lah dulu… adakah koridor-koridor itu dah/tengah dilaksanakan?
He is correct Doc… ETP pun camtu gak!
EtP is moving. Please recheck facts.
Are those koridor-koridor proposed by Pak Lah itu masih alive?
Ecr and johor corridor yes. Sarawak corridor on becoming energy state is on full steam. You can read these in business papers.
Faekah mentioned in the video she welcome anyone who wishes to seek her help. Probably, DrR should consider to meet her…
I would like to meet her… how long is the line?
I will call her
Doc,
On item 4 – we always get the same sales speech of the GDV of so and so RM. I will also not forget the GDC as at the end of it all we look at Gross Profit to be meaningful to the stakeholders.
Hi DrR, have you watched the following Youtube:
It’s about Alam Perdana… is the UKAY case you fight for similar?
Ukay Bistari different issue
Alam Perdana – Issue still unresolved till today. Read post VICTIMS@Alam Perdana post
Thanks DrR for clarification.
Ukay Bistari is a simpler issue where practically all units (except some held by the developer and close associates) have been sold and the the project which was supposed to be handed over in Aug 2006 is in various stages of construction. No land issues. There is a shortfall of RM 15M-20M on the cost to complete the project (including 2 blocks stalled at piling stage).
Victims UKB requested both FG and SSG to inject the sum of money as advances to ease cash flow collaterised against the units kept by the developer and close associates and other assets but both declined Victims UKB request.However, KPKT is working closely with Victims UKB to arm twist/push the developer to complete construction and resolve issues and this is not been easy with the recalcitrant developer. The problem is that hiding behind the corporate veil the person behind all this mess, TSCAC is protected under the law as his name does not appear anywhere to go for legal action.However applying political pressure from both sides of the political divide, he is , I guess, forced to ensure the project is completed, units handed over to purchaser and compensation givers to purchasers of the said 2 blocks, where the developer has no financial means to restart work. He knows, Victims UKB is using all avenues to force the developer to fulfill its obligation and he has been visiting the site and monitoring progress regularly.
This guy is known to practise not only”lu tolong gua-gua tolong lu” but “gua takmahu rugi” and makes it difficult for parties trying to assist to muscle him.
the chingkie cac is a true -hard-core-chingkie with his straight hair
as the only straight thing about him.
it would appear not only chingkie like cac and Dr lim are slick , they can
whisper sweet nothings to the authorities to get things done such that they
can get advances and reduction in liablities. That is why mca wants to hold the fort in kpkt!
2. Dr Rafick
Do not get into the nitty-gritty of being a counsellor. You should go for exco/
adun for b/a. I hereby propose Dr Rafick as our nominee for B/A.
TSKI – if you are reading this , take note. You do want a winnable candidate for B/A.
True… propose DrR as an independent candidate for BA Adun in the GE13…
Doctor, wonder if this extract from RPK’ What do you mean by ABU? can or cannot influence your bashing of the Selangor:
“See what happened in Selangor with regards to the key positions in the state administration. It was all done against the wishes of Pakatan Rakyat and it was, again, all Umno. So we have a Pakatan Rakyat state government with an Umno administration.”
Doctor, hope you don’t mind this off topic comment but the information is important for the nation in view of the impending general election.
There is a post at How votes are bought in Malaysia and how it can be made difficult
http://pray-for-malaysia.blogspot.com/2012/01/how-votes-are-bought-in-malaysia-and.html
Which explain everything. I hope the information posted there can be circulated as widely as possible. For those intending to become polling agents as well as trainers who may not be aware of such going on’s please read the post or forward it to them.
Thank you Doctor and hoping for a brighter future for Malaysia.
I always read your coloumn but sometimes do criticize some of your comments that you label against the PR govt, especially in SELANGOR.
DR R- Thank you
I know you may have stone to grind with Azmin but that should be a separate issue. I hope Azmin is reading your columns.
DR R- You are wrong. Nothing personal but more on the professional level where I question his poor level of service to BA
Coming back to the issue of competency which you suggest are the first of the three motto of PR. You also say that, a competent government is a government that is able to run things efficiently and the effect can be felt when ordinary people is dealing with the various state government agencies. But you also mentioned Penang. You are wrong there.
DR R- Why is it wrong? I don’t understand. If you read my previous post, I said very clearly that I cannot comment much about other state as I don’t live there and when you read you must read within the context of my locality. I can’t be repeating this in every post than my post would be very long. Hope you understand
Be specific of the PR state you want to comment. You only know about Selangor, even that is based on your experience you have dealing with the issue of your residential areas, the issue of land slips at your areas etc. Whatever happened to your suggestions made to PDRM regarding the morning jam at MRR2.
DR R- My suggestion was considered but was not taken up fully. They took up some of it. Those suggestions were made after DUKE opens. You must also appreciate the jam is getting worse everyday beyond what the police can do as the number cars grows exponentially. In KL the new car registration is over 24% per annum on year to year basis. The number of SOV is very high in the morning. The roads has no room for expansion. What else do u expect the police can do. If you have some practical solution I am willing to push it up.
I find it’s even worse after the opening of the DUKE especially at Hulu Klang where the DUKE exits into MRR2. There are tons of issues involving the FEDERAL Govt which you hardly pick up to fight with them. Why only go after the state govts under PR. Look also at the BN run states. Be Fair.
DR R- If you read my blog regularly then you would appreciate I attacked both sides consistently
Lets go back to the issue of state govts and the local councils. As its a known fact that all state councils be it MPAJ, MBSA or where ever it is, the Ministry of local Govt has the wheeling hand on these ajencies. This is where the state govts lose out. All is controlled by the Minister of that Ministry.
DR R- Not true. The YDP is seconded from Federal but appointment must be consented by the states. The FG has very little say on the running of local government. The FG funds cannot be allocated directly to LA but must go through to the State Government. One such example is MARES fund.
So, please go after that Minister as well, don’t always bite the person who is always bitten and under threat. I have seen how the President or Chairman of these agencies ‘FRUSTRATES’ the MP or the ADUN from the opposition when they deal with them.
DR R- It does happen but it happened because SSG do not know how to use their powers effectively.
Even the small ‘fry’ at that office can hold the ADUN at ransom So, this is where the ADUN always fails because they are bound to as long as the ajency is under the Federal Authority.
DR R- Not true. The small fry are state employees
Thats why PR must take over PUTRA JAYA. Then we give them time frame. That is where we go after their skin if they fail. Today, I don’t blame the opposition MP’s or ADUN’s. As a doctor, you can see what goes on in the Malaysian Parliament, where the opposition brought issues no matter how important they are never GET TABLED. Why? If you can master that then you can imagine the worst case scenario happens at the lower agencies.
In SELANGOR, how the JAIS, MAIS have frustrated the MB. They carried out programme that went against the PR govt aspirations. Who presides over these agencies?
DR R- The sultan
Who nominates these people? Is the same with the local Councils. The Councillor nominated by the PR govt is also restrained.
DR R- I suggest you talk to Derek Fernandes and he can tell you how powerful is the council in MBSA because the council members are knowledgeable and is able to control the meeting clearly. In MPAJ the quality of local councillor is below Par
They can only talk@NATO. I don’t blame them. They are programmed to fail the people by the FEDERAL GORMEN.
Guess, its suffice to say, there is no way a state govt can achieve in its goals in the councils as long as the nomination or council heads are done by the BN govt.
DR R- The council as a group has bigger power than the head!
So, lets bring down the BN in PRU13 and see the difference. What the BN could not do in Penang for 54 years has been proven by LGE that DAP can do the job. They have set the financial accounts into black in the former once almost bankrupt councils.
DR R- If you are talking about the reduction of state debt from RM630mill to merely RM30mill, I suggest you read more about it. The debt was sold to FG in exchange of the water assets that the FG bought thorough PAAB. It is not as if they manage to generate such a big income that they were able to reduce the debt. This we must be clear. On the other hand, I agree and has repeatedly says that I believe Penang Government under LGE is doing much better based on the little things that i know.
They are giving the highest grant to the RELIGIOUS COUNCIL of RM60 million compared to a RM12 million by UMNo/BN govt. The Selangor govt is fighting with the Federal govt over the water issue.
See, how they are trying to force the state to agree with them in order to give life to their crony at puncak niaga. Tell the people how much they are going to end up paying for the water bills in the long run if the BN takes over the state.
DR R- Please read my old post about this. I fully support what MB is doing on this issue. Ellese and me don’t see eye to eye on this
I am not a learned person but along the way, I pick up things that effect the people and I feel frustrated because I cannot indulge in politics. But Its the welfare of the people that is pushing me to write whatever I can master. Maybe I am wrong here and there, it’s understandable as I am not a BA honors graduate like you or your other visitors at your blog.
One thing I can undertsand is the difference between DEFICIT AND SURPLUS BUDGET. So, please talk about the budget and the ‘you tolonggua gua tolongyou’ policy adopted by the Prime Minister.
I just cannot understand how a father can go to the bank to borrow money, only to give it to his disgruntled children to make them happy about him. By doing so, he mortgage’s his property. Who is the loser?? So, please doc, you are learned person compared with me, please tell the rakyat, Is this the right thing to do. Just to get VOTES you are distributing money that’s not even yours in the first place.
DR R- I agree with you 300% on the last point
Abdullah
Wow ! so long! I will try to read and reply in detail later.
But for now if you read my articles regularly, I hit both sides and even local authority. I suppose off late you read my articles criticizing the SSG and PR. Why? because I love them and I don’t want them to fail! At the rate they are going they will fail.
You seem to be echoing RPK?
thats your perception. i based on facts
i think the reader prefer you to love BN more
Dear Abdullah, as Dr Rafick said, don’t believe with what he said unless it agrees with your own common sense. He pasted two photos of AA here, Heck, it is his blog.. we can comment…either he is slightly nuts or obsessed!
Sally,
Must ask Dr Rafick for the date of PRU13 as he has started the lobbying and campaigning !
that is for me to know and for you to find out on what Najib whispered to my ear!
Why some people use wild imagination to excuse incompetence of those they support while use wild imagination of bad faith to deny competence of whom they don’t support? Why is it difficult to apply the same standard?
How come when pr has a deficit budget it’s okay but bn has deficit budget it’s not. Its a funny world we live in. People get duped and conned by politicians all the time.
today pkns has exco mtg.9 30 to 1pm.yb teresa,iskandar and azmin ali was there.gm othman and timbalan ghani was there.
gm boasted last 3 yrs of 14bil gdv but ZERO delivery.
rumah mampu milik in sri termenggong gombak..XERO delivery.sports city kelana jaya ZERO delivery…11,000 rumah mampu milik ZERO, bernam jaya
ZERO..selangor science park 2 ZERO…
GM useless fight with timbalan en ghani.THEY HATE EACH OTHER
as houseowner in ba, I am happy with
the services given by mpaj. I have asked them to
cut threes which looked like falling on to my house.
They did. I asked them to get the drains at the back of the house repaired.
They got it done asap. But all the jobs were critical in nature as the house is
standing on a slope.
These were the great services rendered by mpaj. But I am not sure if
your highly rated MOH would render a great service to the penduduk
of taman kelab ukay.
U see when we bought the house at kelab ukay, the model at the
sales office [ Then lipkland , now transformed as Petaling Tin]
had a development model with kelab house, swimming pool and
tennis courts. The pool was planned to be in the kelab house.[ok]
But the tennis court were supposed to be in front of my house. But the
company built the courts in the compound of the clubhouse and the
land on which the bungalows were supposed to be built was sold
so that the new owners built a bungalows on it. And the club after some
years of operation were leased as an insurance office-which one can see as one approached
taman Kelab Ukay from jalan sertind/sering which lead to ukay perdana.
The original purchasers of the houses in taman kelab ukay is far and few
and probably as malaysian do not care for such ‘small’ things.
What can the moh do to give back the rights to the facilities promised to
house owners there many of whom are secondhand buyers as
this is also a revived abondoned housing project revived by the Bank Negara [TPPPT]
And I wonder what yb Azmin can do to help the house owners at taman kelab ukay.
the land on which the courts were supposed to be built was sold. And bungalows were built on it.
Penduduk can no longer use the facilities of the club.
You need to look at the SPA and see if the club facilities is part and parcel of your unit. If it is then you need to engage a legal council to fight your case and demand for the usage of a club or find a compromise in the form of compensation or given the rights to use another club
Since you seem to have a penchant to use as few words as possible in your posting, then perhaps rather than explaining that fact, the title of the post should be edited to Competency: SSG first name?
Sorry this should have been a reply to Dr Rafick’s response in the thread below.
Doc is writing about PR’s Motto: CAT… Competency Accountability Transparency. We can look forward for Part 3: Transparency, PR Third Name?
http://mimpi-senja.blogspot.com/2012/01/bugatti-veyron-kereta-mokhzani-cukai.html?spref=tw
There is no proviso for a club in the spa.
But, there is always a big but.
if a buyer of such a home were to say-
‘ hey, i bought the house because of the prospect
of playing a few rounds of tennis over the week end..
Then the picture is slightly different. There is an element
of misrepresentation on the part of the developer.
Buyers- I am giving you a swimming pool, a club house and
throw in a couple of tennis courts.. so said the rep of Dr Lim!
And twenty years later, abra cadabra..
no swimming pool, no tennis courts…
Loyar for Dr Lim would go with : ‘ where is the f@@@$ing evidence’
I would say why Lim -chang would name his project: ‘taman kelab ukay’
What now now- a taman without a kelabhouse?
Anyway the point for all this is to point out that I always make-
the only thing straight thing about a chingkie is his straight hair..
so what has other good chinese have to say…..
The melayus in gomen are corrupt . I am not defending that.
Look why did mpaj allowed the use of the kelabhouse be changed
from recreation to a commercial one?
you tolong i, i tolong u kah?
for the info of our readers lim-chang is involved in the karambunai
resort and the new corridors in sabah as part of transbasi of the bn gomen!
addendum—-
———————
at the project revival meeting at a hall in ampang jaya,
a meeting organised by the Bank Negara TPPT, I raised the issue whether buyers
will get a swimming pool, tennis courts and a clubhouse with the chairman -a certain
tuan Haji.
he assured all those present with all those present, that the facilities were part and
parcel of the project. I remembered Arthur Andersen was the project manager. I wondered
how many of our blog followers were at that fateful meeting sometime in the 90′s.
again it would be good if someone can confirm what I have claimed as a matter of
record for posterity.
1. If it is not in the SPA and you signed that it is expected that you will not get a club house. Verbal promises by any parties is not a valid contract.You must remember that you signed a contract with full knowledge of the content.
2. I believe the status of the Club House has never changed until today. Please give evidence that it has changed. I will also reconfirmed from the MPAJ local plan
While not privy to the ongoings of BA I think the point has been raised that it is a matter of misrepresentation for which action can be taken especially if it is is the sales brochure or equivalent
,
,
,
The re-Nego between owners and TPPT/arthur Andersen as the
new trustee for the project
——————————————————————————————
I have alerted some neighbours along the line of misrepresentation and also
and told them to raise issue on the meeting of the project revival.
Like doc Rafik’s failed housing project, owners have discarded the original
spa.and are asked to do a new contract based on mutual
desires [ and probably
not subject to moh spa requirements] . Arthur Andersen [now accenture]
people can elaborate fully.
The meeting represent a fresh renego on the purchase of a failed project
between house buyers and the project directors [tppt] and the project
manager [ arthur andersen , now acdenture].
So record of that fateful meeting in Dewan ahmad Razali are pre-cursors
to a new contract between house buyers and successors of Lipkland and
tppt as project directors and trust owner and vendor of the project.
that is a mouthful of jargons there….
Thx a million
PR should make u our rep in the gomen
at least u stay in the ba and and are aware of the local issues
Doctor, you have addressed the PR as 1 homogeneous group lumping AA and the Selangor Government together with the rest of PR state government. It would be fairer to be more specific as lumping the Penang State Government with the SSG is not fair as the Penang SG and Lim Guan Eng has a better reputation
Your point may be valid but i have repeatedly mentioned in previous post that I live in Selangor and could only give views on situation in Selangor as this is where I live. However I can’t say the same about Penang other than several positive observations that I have highlighted when I visited the island.
Out of curiosity would you apply the same principle to others like PDRM judiciary BN etc ie we should not generalize things?
Dear Doc,
Your points are noted on numerous occasions. It is important but not urgent.
We have urgent and important matters at hand.
I do have a list of PRIORITIES which I would demand from a government.
Sorry to say that, your concern is NOT in my top 10 list, er… neither in the top 20.
My apologies.
Majulah Malaysia!
Thats ok..everyone has different priorities in life. For that matter you and i may not enjoy the same kind of food what more having the same priorities
I support your desire for a more efficient, effective government. But my own reading of the situation is that debating on these issues will almost certainly be ideological rather than analytical. This will do little to illuminate the issues involved. Why don’t you list out all the services which you personally deal and which you perceived as inefficient? To move ahead, we must provide technical answers and not political answers.
ADUN’s services are especially sensitive to political pressures because different constituencies have different issues, objectives and priorities. It would require time to strike a balance between the values of equality, universality, and efficiency. There is no easy answer. If you are “terdesak” and “ADUN mendesak” it may result in a proliferation of costly government social programs.
Be patient, any radical changes of local council and/or the council members will not be easy. It will be resisted by a wide coalition of groups, i.e. administrative, FG, professionals, and other vested interests.
Dear Zul
I have proposed that PR states to do an independent audit on the increase of level of competency and let the people be the judge. I assume we are talking about competency of state government officers and the related agencies.
My dealing with SSG and its agencies mainly involves with MPAJ, MPS and the land office. Based on my assessment there is no dramatic difference is ability to handle issues, but there is a significant increase in public relation activities in handling clients. The staff tends to be more diplomatic and polite.Turn around time on issues did not show any significant improvement. Processes has not changed.
At the state level, why are they not able to do a smooth transition of councillors as per the 12 months term? Every year it is delayed as there is an infighting on numbers allocated to the political parties. This is simple exercise only.
Doc,
Correct me if I am wrong. There are already changes in the MPAJ councillors since firts nominated in 2008. Taman Melawati (Zone ?) had Hj Wahab and now Hj Yazid. BA (Zone?) had Izzuddin replaced by someone else. I thought councillors are nominated every 2 years in May?
No
Councillors are appointed once a year and can only serve the maximum of 3 terms under the Local Government Act. In the case of current council member in PJ their terms has been extended another one month while SSG finalize the new list. In Ampang, <strong>MPAJ website</strong> list the Ahli Majlis sesi 2010/2011. Now is 2012. Their term has been extended for one month as well pending finalization of allocation of seats among the political parties
You should write to the MB and request for explanation on the delay in SSG finalising the list. Mana tahu your name is in the list for MPAJ ha!ha!
Nama i mana boleh masuk list kalau tak dicalunkan oleh PKR or PAS or DAP!and by the way the MB has a poor record of replying letters!
I tak tahu lah what actually really happen between you and AA… I can feel that AA has crossed your limit of forbearance. I do hope and pray that AA will come to his senses and pass to you his peace pipe..
Becareful with his peace pipes……………………… you nevr know where its been ,or who have been using/ smoking it……………Doc, bring Dettol to clean it ,it kill 99% germs.
Thank Zul
We got to practice safe peace pipe smoking
:)
Just smile, jangan marah nanti kena jual
oops sori Doc.. it should be “sekapur sirih”… peace pipe is more for the Red Indians…
In the terms of the navy, we say he has crossed my bow to the limit that I could no longer tolerate. Such a foolish man that do not serve his constituency and yet put in no effort to get closer to the people
How about shisha pipes .. boleh? More arabic lo!
Sure boleh lo…. but dress code: Arabic/Long and loose lo..
:0:0:):):):):)
Smile, it the world better
Frankly, I also do not really like the way AA responses to various issues…
Abdul Ibrahim,
I am no Azmin Ali’s fan due to his over handling in Sarawak election. What about Azizan’s remark on AUKU? That’s even teruk right
Azizan is too confident…
Confident?
Azizan Abdul Razak at the MB seat is shaky. Could be a one term MB.
Not only AUKU, the pass few statements while being a MB was rather undiplomatic.
When one becomes over confident, he tends to be ego…