Dear YB Azmin Ali
-
I do hope this letter finally reaches you through your political network one way or another. My aim is to highlight to you our frustration of the level of service (disservice) from you as an elected MP/ADUN. It is the same advice that I gave your predecessor Azman Wahid (UMNO-BN BA) a year before the 12th General Election. Azman Wahid was my school mate back in Ipoh. I bumped into him at Tesco Ampang several months after the 12th GE and he told me that he should have taken my letter to him seriously. I told him that it is too late now and no point thinking about it. He will never regain the trust of the people in BA.
-
The purpose of me writing to you is to remind you that we the people who elected you expect some service. Right now that is sorely missing. As ADUN of BA I expect you to play your part to raise important issues related to BA people in the Dewan or to the State Government. It is the same as for being the MP of Gombak.
-
I have been following you, Anwar and several others on twitter for several months now. The thing about technology is that if it is not properly used it can back fired against you. Trough out the time when I was following you, I could tell where you are exactly every time of the day and night. For e.g. this week when the Parliament was in session you were in Taiping with Khalid Samad. I had expected you to be in Parliament and address issues of relevance to the country.
-
What is probably most frustrating is that I sent you several SMS, an email and on twitter asking you to raised some questions relating to the usage of the power of the minister in protecting purchaser interest in Parliament. I did not get any respond from you. Is it so difficult? After all, I had given you a write up, a section of the relevant ACT and the necessary questions which have an important impact on the fate of abandon property owners in Malaysia. All you need to do is to find the opportunity to ask but did you? How can you ask a question when you are not even in Parliament when the Parliament is in session.
-
Please tell me whom have you seen or what have you done to help your constituents in resolving the abandon housing issues? Your own political party members in BA are the victims of the same project. Please tell me how many minutes of your time that you have spent to help the fate of 2000 property purchasers in Ulu Kelang.
-
Parliament question time is limited. Instead of making full use of it, half of the time has been taken by the “jumping beans” and now by Anwar on its APCO issues. You also use your time to defend Anwar on the APCO issue. What is so important about APCO that it needed to be raised in parliament?
-
Records will show that Anwar first brought up this issue. Please excuse me for saying this outright. So what if 1-Malaysia is copied by 1-Israel or 1-Antarabangsa or 1-Balakong? If through 1-Israel, it made Israel one of the strongest country in the Middle East then there is no harm if Najib wants to follow the same recipe? As long as we don’t end up behaving like Israelis we are fine.
-
Malaysians are neither blind nor stupid. Most of us can appreciate the between the slogan 1-Malaysia and the reality behind it but wasting parliament time by raising such issues is counter productive. It does not help anybody.
-
Saudara Azmin, I valued some leaders of PR like TSKI for his professionalism and hard work and YB Zuraidah who at least try to help me. It is my prayer that PR continue to rule Selangor for another 5 years but my worry is that people like you will bring the downfall of PR. My members are really upset with the poor progress of the Ukay Bistari project. What makes people angry is that both Anwar and you told us that you will help us but reality is nothing has been done.
-
I twittered Anwar on Sunday and asked him about his promises. He only replied to me after several reminders from me and another friend. He claims that he missed my twitter because he was busy preparing to answer question related with APCO! But fall short to address our question about his promises. That really frustrates me because he brought this irrelevant topic to Parliament and wasted the limited parliament session time. In reality APCO has no impact on Malaysian lives.
- Just because some of the office bearers are Jews, he wants to make a political mileage. It upsets me that you backed him up at the expense of people like us who wants you to ask relevant questions. Questions that will have an impact on the people whose property has been abandoned nationwide by the developers.
My advice to you is change or be prepared to be changed. Take my word for it.
Advertisement
This is so nice to read DRRaffick, I’m so glad I subscribed. God bless you and your family
PUHKB,,
Congratulations and Thank you to Pakatan Rakyat,, on the motion being heard in Parliament,,,,,,with regards to the Failed Bistari Housing Project left behind by,,, Barisan Nasional Ruling Government.
THIS IS A DAWN OF AN NEW ERA,,,,, for the citizens of Malaysia to,,,,,, have been given their rights to be represented in voice,,through PR Representatives.
dramrit sekhon,
The credit should go to DRRAFICK.
After his ‘struggle and warning’ then ONLY the so call MPs hessitatingly ‘lend’ their voice to DRRAFICK in the parliment.
CONGRATULATION AND THANK YOU DRRAFICK.
terima kaseh juga kepada mp yang sudi mendengar rungutan positif rakyat.
rakyat ini macam ibubapa, mp macam anak. ibubapa sediakan segala ‘prasarana’ untuk anak anak belajar.tapi bila anak yang dijadikan ‘ayam tambatan’ keluarga tidak menunjukkan ‘kesungguhan’ dalam usaha belajar tentulah ibubapa akan rasa gundah gulana, sedih dan rasa hampa.
anak anak yang ‘menghampakan’ hasrat murni ibubapa tidak pernah berjaya dalam hidup dalam ertikata sebenar kehidupan.
renung2kanlah.
you are most welcome. we should thank YB Zuraida Kamaruddin P 99 Ampang
drrafick,
sudah dijangka! if not this ‘angel ‘ or ‘nightingale ‘ of Ampang who else!
‘ I guess we have to find a good independent party-less candidate’ dr Raffick.
Dr,
Next GE 13 Ibrahim Ali will be an Independent party-less and base- less candidate!
A very intelligent and vociferous man but with a pea brain!
He’s for grab.
A ha.
He does not meet my requiements
D’mrk
Very few independent candidate can get elected unless they have national stature. If they have, they were probably part of the BN govt. Sharir Samad was one who got elected as independent. In Bukit Selambau history was created when an unknown independent, Arumugan defeated the BN candidate in straight fight when the PKR candidate was disqualified. This was only possible due to the anti-BN tsunami.
So like it or not, we need political parties to advance a political agenda. Independents usually lose their deposits. In the Bukit Selambau by-election, 13 independents took part hoping to repeat Arumugan’s feat. They all lost their deposit.
Got this from AA to my twitter
From: @AzminAli
Sent: Apr 1, 2010 5:16p
@_hafiz content full of lies and ignorance. Already explained to maker via email. Must substantiate with facts not emotions.
sent via UberTwitter in reply to @_hafiz
Dear Lanwm
(1) Ask him which part is the lie and which part is the ignorance. Be specific. I got his email and due courtesy, I ask his permission to publish his email and my reply in my blog. I am still waiting for his reply for authorization.
Next week when I get the hansard from parliament, I will show who is the BIG liar. Who is IGNORANT!
To be fair, I think Anwar has the interest of the nation at heart when he brought up the APCO issue. He has the right to ask what is Malaysia doing with an unsavoury outfit with Zionist elements and used by rogue regimes and war mongers. If these people get hold of sensitive national secrets will they use it against us one day, for eg., to force our vote at the U.N.? But look at how BN parliamentarians respond to him? Instead of looking seriously into his claims, they are taking action against him. We know who are better MPs here but I’m not excusing Azmin Ali for his lack of service.
The issue of abandoned housing is a pressing one and it will take a long time to solve as long as BN remains in power. Dr. raffick is taking the right path to form a pressure NGO to change laws. It may take a decade before you can see any effect. If we want to shortcut the process, change BN.
Ken
(1) APCO was raised as a line to shut up the Frogs who was attacking him in parliament
(2) APCO is a business entity that is owned by American jews. Their main role is strategic management. This talk of security threat is a good part of a fictional novel created by Anwar. His aim is to defend himself from the frogs and at the same time to slander Najib by saying that Najib is concocting with the jews. He knows how malaysian muslim at large hate the jews and he is capitalizing on it for political mileage.
(3) I have many friends in the intelligence community and I can confirm with you that all this talk about security threat is garbage.
Let us judge a person by his role. He is an ADUN and an MP. What has he done in this capacity? I think PR should do a survey in BA and finds out what people feels about PR and Azmin. My own assessment is that there is a very strong support for PR and very little support for Azmin. Get some independent party to do a survey and we will know the truth.
YB Zuraida Kamaruddin has been shouldering most of his task in BA. This lady has more support of the people here than Azmin.
Dr. Rafick,,
PLEASE,,,,,,,,Strategic Operations Management (SOM) is not a game in politics at all. In politics it senstivity,,,as the way u feel now.
,,,,,You cannot Jeorpadise National Security by Out Sourcing Management of Nation,,, at the hands of a Private Company,,just like you stamp some documents with OSA,,,from your own citizens.
Dr R- The management of the nation is not being outsource.
TO STARTEGISE THE DEVELOPMENT OF AN ORGANIZATION,,, YOU HAVE TO HAVE ASSES TO EVERY ASPECTS OF MANAGEMENT,,,THAN ONLY CAN YOU,,,,,,, JUSTIFY THE MECHANICS OF IMPLEMENTATION ARE OPERATING AS INTENDED.
Dr R- partly correct ji. you only need information that is related to the main task of the strategizor . Not all. In the case of APCO, it is 1-Malaysia and most of the information are available on public domains.
SO CAN YOU REVEAL THAT THEY WERE NOT INVOLVED WITH THE SECURITY OF THE NATION.
Dr R- Without revealing so much and not to betray the trust others have in me, I can firmly say YES that there is no National security threat.
YOUR FRIENDS HAVE MISLED YOU IN THIS CAPACITY,,,. I AM SORRY I HAVE TO BE HARD ON THIS FACTOR,,BECAUSE YOU SPOKE OF STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT AND SECURITY,,,,WHICH ARE ELEMENTS OF NATURE,,,, TO ENSURE THAT IT WORKS WELL,,,,,,
Dr R- We can agree to disagree here.
,,,ITS JUST LIKE ISO 9000,,ITS NOT POSSIBLE TO IMPLEMENT UNLESS,,,THE IMPLEMENTOR CAN HAVE ASSES TO LOCK STOCK AND BARREL OF THE COMPANY OPERATIONS.
NAJIS SHOULD BE CHARGED UNDER OSA AND THAN PUT UNDER ISA.
Dr R- He should be charged for many other things that is punishable under the law.
If at all the Strategic Management by APCO has been put in place,,,than my friend,,the BEHAVIOUR AND ACTIONS OF PDRM, MACC, AG, JUDICIARY AND THE MINISTERS THEMSELVES SMELLS DISATER FOR THIS NATION.
ARE U SAYING WE WILL ALLOW JEWS OR ZIONIST,,,, STYLE OF MANAGEMENT TO BE ACCEPTABLE BY MALAYSIANS,,,,,, FROM A PRIME MINISTER WHO IS A BUGIS.
WHAT HAPPEN TO THE INFORMATION MINISTER WHO HAS BEEN RHETORICALLY IN EVERY MALAYSIAN PRIME NEWS CONDEMING THE ZIONIST AND JEWS AGAINST THE ATTROCITIES DONE ON THE MUSLIM PAESTINIANS.
WHAT HAPPENS WHEN THE PROJECT IS OVER,,APCO GOES AWAY AND THE COUNTRY TURNS INTO SHAMBLES.
NAJIB WILL GO BACK TO HIS ROYALTIES IN SULEWASI AND BECOME ANOTHER RELATION OF THE SULTAN THERE WHILE WE WILL BE GROPPING IN THE DARK.
20 MILLION,,,WHATS THE CUT FOR FAT MAMA?
Dr. Rafick,,
Please tell me who and which company install the communnication system of PDRM?
I am sure your friends won’t fail u on this.
Are you talking about the P4 system..
D’mrk
I was searching for the details but,,,,, beyond my reach now,,,MT had the news printed out sometime ago.
There was a joint company of Jewish stationed in S’pore with our IGP (contact) company involved.
System not sure.
Keep it simple. If APCO has links to Zionism and being Consultant to the Malaysian Government , there is every possibility of a compromise in the secrets of the nation. But is the the reason for bringing up the matter in Parliament- the security of the nation. Nay ! , it is tit for tat.
Whatever said of Indonesia and Malaysia, majority of the population of these 2 countries are from the same stock. – rumpun Melayu or Nusantara . Always at each other throats on small issues but when it comes to the crux, you will see a united force.
Ak,,
ASK NAJIB,,WHEN HIS FATHER WAS THE DEFENCE MINISTER,,,,, AT STALEMATE TIME,,,,, REGARDING THE CONFRANTATION,,, RAZAK WAS SWEATING IN HIS PANTS IN AUSTRALIAN MILLITARY CENTER IN BUTTERWORTH AND FLEW TO NEW ZEALAND MILLITARY BASE IN SINGAPORE FOR 5 DEFENSE NATION ASSISTANCE.
Indon psychology is vastly far away from the malays in malaysia. They are survivors.
Waooo!!! We are talking about exposing the Security of the Nation,,,with the very Zionist that we Shun.
,,,,If it is not Parliament wherelse would u hear about it.
,,,,My worry is that UMNO/BN,,is silently and slighingly,,, the very regime that controls the MSM,,,, is in cohort with a party,, which we do not recognise in Parliament,,,,from day 1.
,,,,,,HOW DO YOU ALLAY THOSE FEARS OF THE PUBLIC ?
,,,,The bistari House issue has been there for many-many years,,,APCO has just sprouted,,,why not nip the bud fast.
,,,,,, Your committee is having miserable time solving the issue, because of the cog,,,being stuck in the mire and you all are being made to run, from pillar to post for solutions and there seem to be no light at the end of the tunnel.
,,,,,,MATE IS SECURITY OF NATION NOT IMPORTANT.
,,,,,,WHAT IS WRONG WITH RAISING A PERTINANT ISSUE?
,,,,,,ARE YOU SAFE IF TOMMORROW INDONESIAN CONQURE US?
,,,,,,ARE U SAFE IF TOMMORROW PHILIPINES TAKES OVER SABAH?
Ji
Lets agree to disagree that APCO concern is about national security….
Ji,,
With full co-operative spirits TRUCE.
TALKING ABOUT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Whatever said of Indonesia and Malaysia, majority of the population of these 2 countries are from the same stock. – rumpun Melayu or Nusantara . Always at each other throats on small issues but when it comes to the crux, you will see a united force.
WHAT WAS MALAYSIA AND INDONESIA DOING IN THE UNITED NATION TRIBUNAL COURTS REGARDING THE ISLANDS IN SABAH?
fighting over sovereignty of a nation
Dr Amrit,
I have always maintained that it is DamaiBistari/Intelbest ( and the Promoter) obligation and responsibility to complete the project. That is why we are running in a circle as the law protects the developer. Prompting from the Federal and State Governments is going to the deaf ears of the developer .We have no choice but to push the Federal Government to amend the Act. For a start we are getting PR MPs to raise the matter in Parliament.
On the Malaysia-Indonesia relationship is like berbalah adik beradik. In the current globalised world it will be less of conquest/acquisations but mergers.
Sorry AK,
I got to agree with Amrit on Indonesia is at throat with Malaysia. In fact, Singapore Grand Old Man LKY is very much closer to Indonesia than Malaysia. Look at the flag carefully. How come, Both Indonesia & Singapore got Merah & Putih. Hehehehe
Malaysia is the most hated nation in South East Asia. Practically every in SEA is offended, that includes Thailand. Why Brunei, who is even more ketuanan melayu than the melayu never join to form Malaysia…..
Limbang district is not over yet for the Bruneians….Just that their army not that powderful…..Well, when Singapore is managing the finances…..Unofficially
Dr R- partly correct ji. you only need information that is related to the main task of the strategizor . Not all. In the case of APCO, it is 1-Malaysia and most of the information are available on public domains.
1 Malaysia is a conceptualization of systems,,,, required to be processed and delivered into the various channels of management,,,whether startegic or relevant.
As an implementor all I need to know is the fundamental structure,,,the rest is application and after that,,,,,, the implementor by sitting thousands of miles away will know,,,,,, what the next move of Malaysia is going to be.
Can’t he sell all these management startegies for more than 20 Million,,,,,to Singapore,,,or even Indonesia who has not forgotten,,,, its claim on Malaysia as Indonesian Territory.
Reminds me of UMNO/BN leaders rethorics on GOVERNMENT SECRETS BEING SOLD TO OTHER NATIONS.
What chance is there not if APCO had done it?
Talking of Indonesian claim ohhh!!!!!Yarrrr,,,,,Najib is a Sulewasian,,,why would he not benefit,,,,,by handing over Malaysia to Indonesia and be nominated a the Governor of Malaysia.
Adding on
PM = Sulawesian Murtad.
DPM = Javanese Murtad.
Defense Minister = Javanese Murtad.
TAR = Thai good relations with North.
T Razak = Sulawesian to early.
THO = Turkish too far.
Mamak Kutty = Indian,,India not interested.
AAB = Persian too far.
NR = All the merrier to join Indonesia,,Malaysian politics have matured beyond comprehension,,there for best is find the easy way out,,,, while at the helm and yet can remain on the helm as Indon subject.
Raffick,
The Management of the Nation is not outsource but it’s compromised. It’s not as simple as you think.
Raffick,
Watch Yes Prime Minister! If a nation like UK’s secrets very much known by Kremlin, think of the sanctity of national security secrets……With APCO, it would be an open secret……\
We don’t wanna wait till another round of Operation Mugabe to expose our vulnerability
Raffick,
Having said that I do admire the Isrealis……I have forgotten the name of the Operation…..It’s perfect….4 C130 flew from Isreal went in and save all hostages……
It’s an open secret that Uganda would be the next Isreal when Isreal itself failed to exist……Idi Amin has second mind……You know what happen to Idi Amin
Abg Ken,
Bagaimana nak tukar govt, jikalau sekarang sikap (konsep kerja) mereka saling tak tumpah macam UMNO/BN… 2 tahun lagii ajer ..
Orang2 macam aku nie yang tiada party skrg dok perhatiii ajer.. orang macam kami nie bila2 masa boleh ambil eraser untuk padam pangkah pada kertas undi.
Salam alaik to all..
thank you DR for the very brave letter post! To be a good leader is someone who are ready to be lead! For me, APCO also is something that VERY IMPORTANT shud be revealed for the people to know, BUT in the same time, if evrybody is raising up the same issues and everybody is trying to protect on ONE HOLE, who are going to protect the other hole?
So, i think this is not the first time people complaining about YB Azmin, sumhow he shud take it seriuosly and make things better and clear. Serving the people are his priority!
Compare to UMNO BN, PR is more relevant to govern, because the people are SICKED with UBN. very much! sincerely, i don’t want because of PR MP’S who are not performed, we loose our vote for the next GE!
Dear Dr ,
Give Azmin a break . You are barking at the wrong tree . You should go after Kementerian Perumahaan and try to revive UK Bistary thru SPNB . Why you are not doing this ? Azmin or PKR Or Selangor State not to be blamed , it’s Talam that screw this project . If you are sincere to make UK Bistary revived , SPNB is the right avenue . The govm formed SPNB for this . If we (Lembah Beringin Pro Term Comm ) can make SPNB to agree to revive our project , i see no reason for you to fail .
P/S Lembah beingin did not materilised bcos at the end we counld not get 70% consent for buyers .
Dear Zackdanial,
Thank you for your advice.
I am with Dr Rafick in the PHUKB committee engaging with the developer, DamaiBistari, JPN/KPKT who are monitoring progress of the project and currently regulating the HDA account, the Task Force of the Selangor State Government who has brought in a PMC, RSS Consultancy to bring in rescue contractors to complete the project, the office of the Selangor Sate Economic Adviser who lately has taken interest in the project, Malaysian Trustees representing the bondholders who are interested in redemption of the loans. We have been around since mid 2007 and please do not question PHUKB sincerity in looking after the interest of the UkayBistari purchasers.
The UkayBistari project classified as “project sakit” comprises of Phase 2:
1. 100 units D/S terrace houses
2. 1027 units of service apartments/shopoffices
3. 60 units of PKS
4. 120 units of PKSR
5. 146 units of low cost flats
6. 253 units of low cost flats
The project was supposed to be handed over in mid 2006. It is now in delay to close to 4 years.
What have PHUKB done :
In mid 2007, we convinced 95% of the purchasers to agree to the court order S176. This allowed protection for the developer to complete the project without a winding up worries over their head . This was with the premises the developer promise to undertake completion of the project in stages , the last in Sept 2008. We negotiated with Malaysian Trustees not to wind up the developer when they failed to complete the project as promised in Sept 2008.
During the moratorium period we negotiated with SPAN and SYABAS to allow temporary water supply to be connected to the 100 units D/S terrace houses, which had actually been substantially completed way back in 2006. Hence, TCF was issued to this package and purchasers received their keys in May 2008.There was hardly any construction progress for the rest of the project.
In late 2008 we brought in the Selangor State Government through the Task Force headed by YB Saari Sungib to facilitate and put pressure on DamaiBistari to restart the project. RSS Consultancy was brought in to find rescue contractors to complete the uncompleted units.
At the same time we engaged with JPN/KPKT to also put pressure on DamaiBistari. To protect monies from balance of the purchase price, we got JPN/KPKT to regulate the HDA accounts. The developer was using collections from progress billings to pay more for their own administrative expenses rather than paying contractors. Only after a long battle did DamaiBistari eventually agreed to JPN/KPKT instruction in Sept 2009.
The modus operandi for payment to the rescue contractors are through progress billings from the balance of purchase price and partly through contra on unsold properties. This did not work as cash flow was the biggest issue. Contractors were not paid for work done and they just could not sustain completing the project using their own funds. The Promoter ( we suspect TSCAC ) to DamaiBistari had countless time promised to inject funds through sales of land and properties. These were empty promises as until now the deals have not materialised. We are pursuing this matter through both JPN/KPKT at Federal level and the Selangor State . We are leveraging on the good office of the MB as TSCAC/TALAM and MB Inc have some sort of a Settlement Agreement and because TSCAC through his nominees and proxies has a lot of land banks in Selangor.
RSS Consultancy have managed , though contractors have not been substantially and fully paid, to complete the 146 low cost flats. A big do was organised by PR in mid Feb with YB DSAI, YB Azmin, YB Iskandar, YB Zuraidah, YB Saari among others in attendance in the handing over of keys to purchasers. In the speech , PR made it their renewed agenda to rehabilitate abandoned housing in Selangor . Knowing that problem of abandon housing is more of the Federal matter, PHUKB requested PR MPs to bring up the matter in Parliament . The impression that I got (you can say a promise) is that it would be done.
zackdanial
I believe AK has given a good summary on what has been done. However a summary does not show the total man hours involved, the frustration we faced, the empty promises that was give and lack of will power by the state and federal government to solve the issue of abandon housing. The state while having the upper hand only wants to function as a mediator role. The Federal government despite having the laws on his side, dont want to use them.
For record, Anwar shook my hand and said “Dr, we will help.. dont worry” …. so far NOTHING… damn frustrating
See our wonderful parlimentarian in an interview with an international news agency.
See: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CBHAMp0-bLc
Are we sure we want them to represent us as Malaysian policymakers?
Well, you decide.
Salam Doc,
Can i know to whom (authority) we can get the letter to say that this ukay bistary project is bermasalah or if not terbengkalai…?
regards
You can contact KPKT and speak with Ir Lai Liang Koong, Pengarah Perumahan Swasta
One day when we have a robust 2 party system then politicians will be taken to task. Either they give good service or be booted out. Problem is, we now have an emerging 2 party system which is still a baby and it is under severe attack from BN.
Will the baby survive? This is by no means certain. BN is using every dirty trick it can to break up PR including, police, MACC, judiciary, royalty, seducing PAS, baiting PAS, bribing elected reps, sedition charges, illegal assembly, biting policeman, sodomy charge, etc.
We also seem to hold PR to a higher standard than BN. If an Umno MP never reply to your SMS will you shrug it off as ‘biasa’ or blast him in a blog?
Of course we expect more from PR than BN but let’s not whack the baby until it dies and then we only have BN in a 1 party system. You won’t like this dr. raffick, not at all.
Jeff
What I did was trying to get Azmin to raised a specific question in parliament with the intention of locking Minister of Housing to use his power under the ACT 118. It frustrate me because he did not respond to my request via sms,call,email,tweeter. Luckily I had asked YB Zu to do the same as a backup plan and what need to be asked was finally asked yesterday at 12:37pm. I am now waiting to get the Hansard. In the end YB Zuraidah delivers.
So your questions was asked already…does it matter who ask the question…?
Or you have personal vendetta against azmin…hehe
Tres
Why do you think so negatively. Let me put the record straight
(1) When the request was first sent to Azmin about 2-3 weeks ago, he did not respond. I chose Azmin because the UKB project is under the Gombak Parliament Constituency.
(2) Since he did respond, I had to prepare a back up plan where I ask YB Zu who is the MP for Ampang (and BA) where I live. YB Zu responded immediately
(3) Yb Azmin responded a few days ago after I sent two clear hints in my blog
(3) On the 1/4, YB Zu asked the question in parliament. Azmin sent me an email between 4-5 pm saying that he asked the question in parliament. I asked a few others MP who was in the dewan and they said they did not see Azmin in the Dewan. To give him the benefit of the doubt, I will wait for the Hansard next week. I hope he did not lie to me. If he did he will receive the full brunt of UK Bistari purchasers (4000 votes)
(4) Trust this clarifies
ohh yeahhh…ohh yeahhh baby.
Walaupun aku benci UMNO/BN tapi jika PKR/PR juga semacam seperti mereka so no harm dan saya bersedia untuk tukar vote.
Man without Party
BN atau PKR atau JKR semua pun sama ,Janji Konket Rakyat!
each of us has only one vote……
in defense of the truth,here…
first,the adun of hulu klang is yb saari sungip.
secondly,the ukay bistari rehabilitaiton project is headed
by saari sungip.
thirdly,the unit are meant for less affordable ‘rakyat’.
fourth,if you bought it from private developer and gained
from it,would you have give some to the state?
so what your truth?
joe
Johan 5150/Joe
The project is indeed in Ulu Klang and the ADUN is YB Shaari. The Abandon Project Task Force is is indeed headed by YB SS. The units that are involved in total is in excess of 1800 units. It consist of D/s Terrace, service apartments, low cost, medium cost, shops and office. The issues that I ask Azmin to raise in Parliament is pertinent to all nationwide abandon property owners. Azmin is the ADUN in my area and also the MP of Gombak where the project is located. He is the right person to raise the issues.
When we owned completed properties in Selangor, the state benefits from two aspect (1) Socio economic (2) Various land and quit rent tax .
The truth is that you dont like me raising my question against Azmin/PKR because you are too “taksub” with him and the party. You need to be objective.
The state and the federal government has the moral responsibility to solve abandon housing issues in Malaysia
dear doc,
tq for response.i know him since 1986.he is a hardworking committed person.i m sure he is aware
of your concerns and will deliver result.
pkr must shift from politics of destructive to constructive criticisms,politics of fear to politics of
hope,politics of talking to politics of doing,politics of
command and control to politics of consensus and cooperation,politics of self interest to politics of
serving the voters n people.
pkr’s mistake in selangor so far has been to retain
and empowers it’s pentadbiran’s civil servant,glcs,
town council pengarah and ydps.these are umno boys
and they will award tender and jobs to bn groups.
suasa efektif bhd is umno owned and they control
parking at 7 selangor town council.pkr led govt has
renewed their contract for another 10 years.they say how foolish pkr is.
they have not paid mpaj 640k plus 330k last three months.guess what is pkr led govt doing about it?
nothing.
guess that money will go to palanivel for this by
election. huhu..
Let’s stop the blaming game. PR politicians must do it differently. Just treat the rakyat as apolitical and provide opportunities to the deserving regardless whether they are BN or PR supporters or they are fence sitters. But oppotunities given must not be taken lightly and if found useless penalised them. The fear of wanting support from every Ali, Ah Chong and Muniandy and put to ransom by them is going to be PR’s downfall.
Dear Dr.,
Quote
My advice to you is change or be prepared to be changed. Take my word for it.
Unquote .
And pray tell…. who are you intending to
replace him with ? Azman Wahid or Gang, again ??
Then after that term of disappointments…
switch back to Azmin & Gang again ?
If not , then please tell me whom you and the 2000 others would want to take over to work for the People .
You issued a justified complaint/advice and I hope you have a suitable candidate to champion your issues.
Salam.
JTBA
I guess we have to find a good independent party-less candidate…
Bila tak dilayan bising sana bising sini macamlah si Azmin tu wakil rakyat Bukit Antarabangsa. Orang lain di kawasan Parlimen Gombak pun ada beribu lagi masalah.
Dr R- Azmin adalah ADUN BA. Kalau tak yakin sila semak laman web SPR. Adakah dia sedang menyelesaikan masalah anda di gombak?
Masalah projek rumah terbengkalai ni bukannya macam masalah longkang tersumbat atau kesibukan lalulintas.
Ianya berkait-paut pada banyak faktor terutamanya undang-undang. Mustahil untuk diselesaikan dengan segera.
Saya di antara beribu orang yang telah ditipu oleh developer. Dah bertahun naik turun pejabat pemaju, pejabat peguam dan juga kementerian yang berkenaan. Dah beribu duit habis tak termasuk bayaran kepada bank.
Saya dah dengar beratus rungutan dari kawan2 lain yang senasib dengan saya. Sudah bertahun merana. Dah hampir nak putus asa.
Hanya satu pengajaran yang saya dapat iaitu bila nak beli rumah (idaman) buatlah kajian tentang pemaju dan kontraktornya.
Wakil rakyat macam Azmin dan yang lain tidak akan dapat menolong orang macam saya sebab masalah ini perlu diselesaikan melalui ‘political will’. Sekiranya kerajaan pusat, kerajaan negeri dan semua ‘key-player’ tak bermuafakat, masalah ini TIDAK akan selesai.
Dr R- Itu sebab saya minta azmin timbulkan soalan di Parlimen. Tanya soalan itu tanggungjawab MP. Kalau saya sendiri boleh tanya, saya dah tanya tapi UNDANG2 kata hanya MP saja yang boleh tanya.
Kalau nak kata saya marah dan geram tentang hal ni, saya rasa saya dah sampai ke satu tahap yang tiada lagi perasaan saya terhadap musibah yang menimpa saya.
Jadi tuan doktor, janganlah tuan doktor marah sangat ke wakil rakyat itu. Ada banyak lagi benda yang kita patut dan berhak marahkan….
Dr R- Saya tak suruh dia cuci longkang atau baiki jalan berlubang. Saya suruh dia tanya soalan di parlimen. Soalan dan fakta saya kaji dan beri padanya. Dia cuma perlu tanya saja. Saya kecewa kerana (1) Tak jawab sms (2) Tak jawab email (3) Tak jawab twitter. Bila saya tulis dalam blog baru la di hantar satu sms dan hari ini dia hantar email kat saya. YB Zuraidah tak macam itu. Saya hantar sms, pasti dia balas dalam masa 2-3 minit. Kadang kadang sertamerta. Perbanding sikap dua MP ini didalam servis kepada masyarakt ibarat langit dan bumi
Dear Dr Khan,
I’d like to interview you for an article on aspects of Malaysian society – could you get in touch so I can email you some questions.
Regards,
Rebecca Omonira
i can see a big character gap between yb zuraida n yb azmin….
remember once i sms both of them ooppss..actually 3 of them including yb saari regarding tanah runtuh..just behind my house…
yb zuraida reply to my sms immediately….yb saari took almost 12 hours to reply…yb azmin…till date…no reply….
at first i thought ok…maybe yb azmin was too bz….especially during that time….DSAI was the PM-in-waiting + we have the numbers syndrome…!!
2nd time was during UK Bistari demo at Maxisegar…
i sms’ed both yb zuraida + yb azmin…
yb zuraida as always..immediately replied to my sms…eventhough she was performing her HAJ at that time…she even asked her officer to come n meet us
and as always YB Azmin…till date no reply…
maybe yb azmin is too bz…try to keep safe his VP post in PKR…while he is aiming for the DP of PKR in the party election….too much politicking…..the people is suffering…
tq doc for bringing this up!
My support goes to YB Zuraida. Very responsive, hardworking and people oriented. No matter how much she tried to cover for her colleague but YB Azmin has to deliver.
I absolutely agree with DrR’s message in this post. A MP or ADUN should pay equal attention if not more in airing the plights of his/her constituents and better still do something concrete about those plights. The average Joe Voter normally give more weight to issues that affect him on daily basis.
Politicking on the APCO issue need not be a parliamentary matter at this stage. If there are documents to prove APCO’s link to zionism, then Anwar, Azmin, and all the PR MPs and ADUNs in Malaysia should just lodge police reports and MACC to complaint of the Government’s complicity with the zionists. They can all do this on the way to Parliament and State Legislatures where they will then have time to raised issues that affects their constituents directly.
I’m absolutely with you on this one Dr.
a million? najib paid apco 20 million contract ok!
Hi Doc,
First, Im against Zoinism and not against jewish people. However, in Malaysia, especially among the muslims, many are ignorant about Zionism. They lump Zionist and Jews as one. Because of this ignorance, UMNO/BN especially Tun Mahathir, has used it to paint Anwar as a freind of Jews. This translated to mean Anwar supports the zionist. This has been goin on for more then 10years ever since Anwar and Mahathir had a falling out.
Dr R- Isnt this is a forgotten old story? Why bring it up again? Anwar didnt raise this issue in defense. He started it this round. If indeed wants to play politics, why do it in the Dewan and waste the precious time of the Dewan
What happened now is, Anwar is simply defending himself and UMNO/BN were caught with their pants down. I agree that its a waste of time and has no direct benefit to the rakyat.
But indirectly, UMNO/BN is trying to discredit Anwar and by doing so, UMNO/BN is hoping that the rakyat (especially muslims) will abandon him.
Dr R- Facts will show that Anwar is the first to raise this issue
Should this happen, then we will lose a key and important person who is leading the change agenda that we are hoping for. Thus, it is important as well for Anwar to defend himself.
Dr R- Sorry Habib. If you follow the sequence of events, you can appreciate that he attacked and not defending while he is suppose to be working
All the same, jews have contributed to the progress of mankind in so many ways. Still, there are also some jews who have wrecked havoc. Lets take the good and discard the bad. I believe that Anwar and Najib should be supported when they take good ones. But they are politicians…..
“I twittered Anwar Sunday….”
Ah Doctor! Very interesting! Using Twitter as communication tool, or more specifically, as a message sender to specific person. I would like to learn how to do it, for example, to Twitter that queen frog/donkey Hee Yit Foong (semi serious).
Can you teach me how to do it? Well not necessary to that despised ADUN who betrayed her constituency and party.
go to http://www.twitter.com Enough instruction there
Doc,
More and more I see the UMNO mentality in PKR politicians. That is ” cakap tapi tak bikin “. Rhetorics and sweet talking , which we call lip service has no place anymore. When a politician say I will do it better do it otherwise do not give the impression that you want to help. Politicians must know that voters are now pretty choosy. We are not interested in party politicking but what you as an MP or Adun can offer to the rakyat, Sorry not RM50/- or higher amount but fighting for our interest.
I agree our MPs (both BN and PR) are making a circus in Parliament debating on issues that I see as trivial as the intention is to make the other party look bad, Security is just a darn excuse. Look like the disease has spread to State Assembly of Perak. What is this Zamry saying that PR offered him to be the MB if he had turned coat. Buat buang masa !
Dear AK
(1) You are absolutely right. He is an ex UMNO that uses a different shades now. I wish he had switched to PR with a new attitude about service unfortunately he did not. He is is still providing lip service only!
(2) I am registering VICTIMS today at 1200.
off course apco has impact on malaysia. please watch the live parliament session and the debate and u’ll know what effect the malaysian have if government continue using apco. i think azmin doing just find, i was in taiping during azmin ceramahs and he said he just got back from parliament.
Tell me in point form what impact APCO has on Malaysian. Please do not use security issue as an excuse. My frustration on azmin is for his lack of response to the people
Well for one, Najib helped this APCO earned over a million of our rakyat’s hard earned money to polish a tarnished UMNO/BN’s image. That is your money too down the drain. Are you not angry Doctor?
Patriot
(1) Let us look at the facts. Be it 1 mill or 20 mill, the govt paid for a service. The service is about promoting Malaysian to be as one.
(2) Anwar did not bring up the issue of APCO because of cost. He did not bring this matter as a wastage of public funds but instead he was trying to play politics of linking najib and zionism.
(3) My issue of contention here is our politicians are playing politics 24/7 but where is the service.
(4) I did not vote Azmin to talk politics 24/7. I voted for him because I had expected service. Unfortunately, in our case (meI and 2000 abandon property owners) have been wrong.
(5) I expect my MP or ADUN to raise issues of relevance to the people and walk the extra mile to solve Rakyat problems. Our trust in him have been betrayed.
D. Rafick,,,
U said u want their service rather then their political rethorics,,,Fine I agree with it. Does MSM gives the bright side of the Pakatan Rakyat,,,,NEVER.
LETS PRESSUME BUT,,,NOT MAKE AN ASS OF OUR SELVES,,,THAT AZMIN HAS TAKEN MEASURES THROUGH HIS ASSISTANT. NEEDING SOME TIME FOR A CONCLUSIVE REPLY OR IMFORMATION B4, HE CAN BE CERTAIN TO DEVULGE IT TO THE VICTIMS OR THEIR REPRESENTATIVES.
Lets give him a benefit of doubt and also with a handful of MPs,,,, in Parliament messing up the status quo of PKR,,he has to tackle that too
Please BRO,,,,only 2 years yet mahhhhh.
Dear Dr Amrit ji
(1) I try my level best to be fair in my criticism.
(2) I am not judging PKR here but merely Azmin Ali in his capacity of ADUN and MP.
(3) I even went to the extent of trying to engage him on specific issues i.e. the abandon housing. I have prepared all the write up and serves him on a silver platter. He does not need to do any research. He just need to be a parrot and read it out in the Dewan. Even if has doubt, he can email me,sms or twitter me but he did not. His silence is damn deafening. He is busy defending his boss on political rhetorism.
Sorry ji, I am really pissed! (with him)
Dr. Ji,
I comprehend from your comments, that you have gone beyond the limits of all parameter fence and found occurances regarding the housing project that,, would have brought things to an abrupt answer and solution.
I can understand ur disappointment especially when u or ur constituency had changed the Adun and MP,, with the hope to solve the issue,,,but rome was not build in a day.
Keep engaging with the MP or the Adun,,coz in my place DAP had the Parliamentary constituency for 5 terms,,,but the Aduns from MCA held the legislature. Aduns were horse trading with electorates to hand the MPship to them so that the problems could be solved.
This time MP and Audunship fell into Pakatan Rakyats hands and with the strike of a pen,,,, our roads are wide,, jams reduced,, sanitary system is wonderful,, health and cleanliness is better,,people are happy and we are on for PR to be here forever.
Housing issue involves Fedral Government ie BN,,,, and what is BN doing to PR states,,,the world is watching.
In summary Engagement would still be the right choice of solution,,,and keep cool yaar!!!!!! Punjabi blood with rotian is garam khoon,,,sabar bhadi cheez hai!!!
Punjabi blood with rotian is garam khoon,,,sabar bhadi cheez hai!!!
Translation:
Punjabis are unsually warm blooded,,, than ususal human temperatures,,coz of wheat flour(Chapatis),,is heaty by nature.
Sabar (as in BM) is a very big element.
“earned over a million…” sorry, correction “squandered over a million of our hard earned rakyat’s money”
Dear all
1Malaysia has brought some good things to our country. DSAI is acting like the old mentality of being opposition MP in Malaysia; everything that is being implemented by ruling party is all wrong.
What are the good things that DSAI & Azmin and the ex-UMNO men in PKR have done since they have become Opposition Leader and members in Parliment? If Azmin who is the current MP of Gombak is acting like the previous MP who was from UMNO, then he has betrayed the trust given by the voters.
DSAI & Azmin simply trying to show off their oratory skills in Parliment to cloud their inability to serve the rakyat ! Malay PKR MP’s in general today are behaving like UMNO MP’s. Why can’t you try to become like Lee Lam Thye, Micheal Chong or Lim Kit Siang; represent and really serve the people.
At this juncture, I believe PKR has failed to deliver !
PKR need to be replaced !
,,,DSAI is an selfish individual and a pain to his family plus the nation. He is the biggest con artist in Malaysian history and shall remain as one for as long as his history is concern.
In fact, he is the biggest trouble maker of the nation, only fighting for his own survival.
,,,most PKR MP’s were failed UNMO MP’s, both teams of failures to the Nation.
,,,We should next time vote for individuals that can deliver for the rakyat and nation. Lets help identify such candidates for the rest to appreciate before GE 13.
,,,ACTION speaks more than WORDs. Keep this simple process in mind too;…..
1. Identify
2. Action
3. Execute
4. Operate
5. Review
Capt,,
CONFUSING BUT INTERESTING
DSAI ex UMNO = Opener of the Can of Worms. Would we have ever known of APCO. At the rate and method,,, Jews or Zionist are keeping the Palestinians at bay,,,does it not occur to you that it has similarities here ,,,, from the PDRM, MACC, AG to Judiciary.
,,,,,Yes possibaly selfish but what he exposes,,,are issues related to individuals in the street. Does it not occur that Kugan, TBH, and others,, who died in the hands of the police,,could one be u or me.
,,,,,Lee Lam Thye,,to save his wifes gambling debts he sold himself and till today has been wipping the arses of National Training Centres where Parents lost their children.
,,,,,Micheal Chong is in cohort with Ah longs and agrees that borrowers,, should return the money loaned, which is illegal to do so,,, but did he ever realise that License Money Lenders are tax payers and loose so much of business.
These Ah longs don’t pay a single cent of Annual License Fee,, neither declare the money loaned to Housing Ministry and don’t even pay a cent of TAXes to Government Coffers.
,,,but he is just full of character with nil integrity !.
,,,i just don’t and can’t trust people like him. Full of promises and talk only, in fact he helped destroy our economy and mess up our educational system in his days. He is also a religious fanatic awaiting in sheep skin.
” Mess up our educational system in his day” ..ya ke.
aku rasa zaman dia la student lagi kualiti dari product Najib dan Hishamudin.
tak ke begitu.
beavie,,,
,,,,,,sekiranya kamu adalah seorang
cikgu [seorang pengajar(cik) yang (gu) gelap], pensyarah di kolej atau uni,,,,,maka kamu akan hairan dengan pelajar2 dari IPTA.
,,,,,,Graduan yang lulus dari IPTA ini,,sekira diinterview,,,u will be suprised at their quality of communication zero (Eng & BM), knowledge, attire, presentation, grammer, general geographycal knowledge, historical knowledge, economical and financial knowledge. You will be suprised.
,,,I have nothing against this kids,,,but their demanour of arrogance,,,,just puts you off.
,,,,,They potray as if they,,,, are the only graduates in this country and we are failures,,,,,, sitting,,,,,, on higher chairs,,,,,, based on cronification.
,,,,,,I suppose this is the nature of mental development they are focused upon when in IPTA and I blame UMNO/BN,,,for filling such info into MSM daily and it has rubbed down upon these graduates,,,,,, without making them realise,,,what the reality is,,,, of the world out there.
Capt,,,,,,
,,,,,,Naahhh,,,,,lets stop the Character Assasination.
,,,,,,Considering the circles of People in Pakatan Rakyat now. Reliable, Creditable and Honest. It is quite visible,,,, that it is rubbing on to him.
,,,,,,As a Opposition Leader,,he has to have the sentiments of all the coalition parties and he will be behaving a little religious democratic, socialist democratic and reformist democratic. Thats the mould he has created,,, since he is leading Pakatan Rakyat and it is endorsed by the other memebers of the parties.
,,,,,,,,,,,,Its an IDENTITY.
,,,,,,That is why Zombies like Zahrain, Zul, Tan, Ezam and some already discarded,,,,, while others are waiting to be discarded,, could not accept the change for the better. These are the guys who,, I would lable as UMNO/BN’s,,unfaced moulds,,causing the problem for a better PR.
dr amrit,
,,,its just a wake-up call, hope for change for the better !. Its just that i call a spade a spade, unless one wants to dig his own grave ?.
,,,interestingly, dr rafick efforts etc is getting the message across.
,,,tried being positive but at times, i don’t mind playing the devil avocate too.
“dont care what color is the cat, as long as it catches the rats”
Capt,,,
Roger!!!!!!!!!
,,,,, I am impressed with AK’s explanation. He has put the whole picture loud and clear,,,, from this on I would give credit for the work, manhours and effort exerted by AK, Dr. Rafick & their Committee,, into solving it,,not forgetting their financial expances.
Lets take another look,,, Talam is UMNO/BN’s proxy. The CEO was with PKNS,,,, before Khir Toyo’s time and later during Toyo’s time,,,,some UMNO/BN politicians joined him,,,so can u see what is to be expected. No need to be explored,,,the wolrd knows.
TRying to engage with Government Agencies regarding failed projects is like,,,,, Looking for a Needle in The Haystack.
,,,,,Its so obvious,,, if any civil servant were to help Azmin regarding this matter,,a can of worms will open up and these civil servant might,,,, end in jeorpady (Al tan the tuya). In,,,,, Talam big crocodiles are involved.
Talam owes PKNS a lot of gratitude as well as money.
THERE IS A VERY BIG PICTURE BEHIND THIS SCENE.